Beeminder vs Sorted 3: Comprehensive Comparison
2
Beeminder vs Sorted 3: Goal Tracking vs Time Management
Beeminder uses financial penalties to enforce goal completion, while Sorted 3 focuses on auto-scheduling tasks and time blocking. These apps serve different productivity needs entirely.
Feature | Beeminder | Sorted 3 |
|---|---|---|
Primary Focus | Goal tracking with financial penalties | Auto-scheduling and time blocking |
Platforms | Web, iOS, Android | iOS, macOS only |
Pricing | Free (3 goals), ~$8/mo + penalties | Free, Pro: $15 iOS, $25 macOS |
What is Beeminder?
• Charges real money ($5-$7,290) when you fail goals
• Tracks quantified goals with visual progress graphs
• Auto-syncs with Fitbit, Duolingo, RescueTime, Apple Health
• Best for repetitive, measurable habits and behaviors
What is Sorted 3?
• Auto-schedules tasks based on duration and available time
• Combines calendar events, tasks, and notes in timeline
• Drag-and-drop time blocking with calendar integration
• Magic Select for bulk task editing and reorganization
Feature Comparison
Feature | Beeminder | Sorted 3 |
|---|---|---|
Time Blocking | No | Yes |
Financial Penalties | Yes | No |
Calendar Integration | No | Yes |
Auto-Scheduling | No | Yes |
Third-Party Integrations | Yes | Limited |
Cross-Platform | Yes | No |
Goal Progress Tracking | Yes | No |
Task Management | Limited | Yes |
Pricing
Beeminder
Free: 3 goals
Premium: ~$8/month
Derailment fees: $5-$7,290
Sorted 3
Free version available
Pro iOS: $15 one-time
Pro macOS: $25 one-time
Key Considerations
Beeminder
• Real money at risk - start small if risk-averse
• Best for automatic, quantifiable habits and goals
• Requires serious commitment and adjustment period to work
Sorted 3
• Apple devices only - no Android or web
• May not be actively maintained anymore
• Limited collaboration and advanced project management features
Verdict
Choose Beeminder for serious habit formation with financial accountability, especially for quantifiable goals like exercise or learning. Choose Sorted 3 for Apple-based time management and auto-scheduling of daily tasks, but consider maintenance concerns.
